• Login
Strong Article
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Investing
  • World
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Submit Article
No Result
View All Result
SUBSCRIBE
Strong Article
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Investing
  • World
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Submit Article
No Result
View All Result
Strong Article
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

How to avert economic collapse – Business Recorder

Muhammad Mubeen by Muhammad Mubeen
1 year ago
in Business, Small Business
0
How to avert economic collapse – Business Recorder
74
SHARES
1.2k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Subscribing is the best way to get our best stories immediately.
The worst kept secret about the present economic crisis is that it has resulted from our rulers having saddled the people with a huge debt while harvesting its proceeds to acquire properties, businesses, and citizenships abroad.
As a result, ordinary citizens as ultimate debtors can no longer pay even the interest payments on this debt (which are growing explosively), without unbearable hardship. The rulers, who contracted this debt on their behalf, would rather emigrate than share the burden. The creditors will not lend more without committing the government to the very policies that got us here.
In this standoff, the creditors’ cartel has captured government and prevailed. Since 1988, we have secured thirteen IMF loans (eight, with policy conditions), each tied to the same generic solutions, each leaving Pakistan in deeper crisis. Even a rat in a maze learns from experience to avoid dead ends and find its way out. Not us. We keep trying the same policies, expecting different results.
This article examines why we do this and outlines alternative solutions to our economic problems.
Given a lock to unlock, instead of trying to unlock the lock ourselves, our knee-jerk reaction is to turn to foreigners (actual, and those who live or have lived among them) to seek advice on what other countries have done.
This is why we are perpetually beating our breasts at our failures and are perennially perplexed at why what works in Xanadu (substitute your country of choice) doesn’t work in Pakistan. It doesn’t work because the Xanadu key doesn’t fit the Pakistan lock.
But this is impossible for our decision-makers to grasp, for four main reasons. One, most lack the capacity to judge arguments on merits and with colonised minds their reflexive tendency is to privilege foreign over domestic advice.
Two, consequently, the policy agenda gets confined to selecting foreign solutions to mimic, rather than working out problem-focused solutions to try. Three, because foreign advisors, usually on a short visit, can offer only generic solutions, they fail in Pakistan. Finally, with the short shelf-life of governments, generic solutions—sweetened by loans—usually win the day. This is the disastrous path all governments have followed and are still following.
To avoid economic collapse, now imminent, we must abandon this solutions-based approach to problems, for a problem-based approach to solutions, with all options on the table. Accordingly, this article outlines, summarily, solutions to the urgent foreign exchange crisis; and, at greater length, to the more intractable problem of restoring fiscal and debt viability.
While space precludes justifications, the foreign exchange crisis can be ameliorated by three obvious if unfashionable steps. One, to stem the rupee’s fall, change the exchange regime and fix the rate at Rs.220 or so to the dollar (or an equivalent basket of currencies), and defend it.
Two, design an appropriate prudential system of capital controls, permitted by the IMF’s Articles of Agreement (VI, s.3) and included in some programmes (Argentina 2002, Iceland 2008). Finally, change official debt policy, to permit only necessary foreign debt; declare a two-year moratorium on additional foreign borrowing; and close deadweight projects with large undisbursed balances of foreign loans.
On the fiscal and debt front, the government should do four things. One, unilaterally reduce its future interest obligations, by restructuring domestic-law debt (following the detailed four-month, six-step, IMF-supported procedure outlined in: How to solve the debt crisis, BR, 22 Apr 2022). Two, reduce policy-determined interest rates on new debt. Three, restore the right of government to monetary financing of the deficit. Finally, undertake comprehensive financial sector reforms.
First, interest due in FY23, in trillions of nominal rupees, would perhaps be around Rs 4 trillion (domestic Rs 3.4 trillion, foreign Rs 0.6 trillion). Immediate action on restructuring domestic debt should lower currently projected interest obligations by some Rs 0.75 trillion in FY23, and around Rs 1.5 trillion in each successive year.
Second, another Rs 1.5 trillion can be reduced by gradually lowering average interest rates by 600 basis points. If it is feared that this will lead to misallocation of credit, then the credit planning system (1972-2006), abandoned at the behest of the IMF, can be revived. Any other negative consequences should be anticipated and addressed in the light of experience, not religious dogma.
Since this flies in the face of well-entrenched IMF dogma, supported by domestic bankers, we are forced to digress to explain why IMF’s convictions don’t hold in Pakistan. From the 1990s, a consensus emerged in industrial countries that monetary policy should target inflation, and actual and expected interest rates determine inflation. But in Pakistan inflation is neither the main policy target nor, empirically, is it determined by interest rates.
So, by its impact on public debt, misguided doubling of interest rates over the last two or three years caused the present fiscal and debt crisis. And by forcing government to mobilise public revenues to pay interest to banks, it enriched the super-rich at the expense of ordinary citizens, contributing to political instability.
It is preposterous that defence expenditures during the last two years were 11 percent less than the Rs 1.4 trillion per year paid in interest to just the top ten banks. Not only should interest rates be reduced, but the entire framework of monetary policy based on inflation targeting by an alienated central bank, mimicking industrial countries, needs to be rethought.
Third, for reasons elaborated at length in an earlier article (‘New’ State Bank of Pakistan, BR, 2 Feb 2022), the government must untie its hands and restore, in principle, its right to borrow from the central bank, if necessary.
This will provide for emergency deficit financing and restore competition in the sovereign debt market. Without competition from the central bank, the banks — a close cartel, with the six biggest banks (two foreign-owned) accounting for 80 percent of assets of all banks — have jacked up interest rates (6-month T-bill from 7.5 percent in Aug-21 to 14.7 percent today) and are quietly making massive windfall profits.
Both steps, however, of lowering interest rates and restructuring domestic debt, must be entrusted to capable hands. This is because the co-dependence of banks and government on each other can create a downward spiral in which a public debt crisis triggers a banking crisis, and vice versa, with one aggravating the other. (In the jargon: the sovereign-bank ‘nexus’ creates a ‘doom-loop’.) Consequently, preparation and sequencing are essential to successful implementation.
Finally, dysfunctional fiscal policies have transformed the banks from being financial intermediaries to becoming sovereign debt brokers. Thus, in 2018-20, sovereign debt constituted the bulk of bank assets in Pakistan (38 percent, up from 20 percent in 2008-10), by far the highest anywhere in the world. In second place, Brazil, this ratio was 25 percent, up from 21 percent. With few exceptions, in most countries it hovers around the 5-10 percent band.
There is a need, therefore, for adapting the logic of the US Glass-Steagall Act (1933, repealed 1999), to separate normal commercial banking from dealing in sovereign debt. In addition, both commercial banks and primary dealers should be discouraged from holding government debt beyond a specified level, by a heavy tax on excess holdings.
There is in fact a consensus, endorsed by prominent central bankers, that the financial sector is long overdue for root-to-branch reforms. While exceptionally profitable in commercial terms, former central bank governor, Yaqub, points out, the banking system in Pakistan is among the weakest in the world, if judged by global standards of sound banking. Banks pay less attention to mobilising private savings for investment, than to channelling tax-evaded surpluses of the rich and advances from the central bank, to government as debt.
The directions of reform can be guided by proposals of former central bank governor, Salim Raza, who calls for a comprehensive restructuring of credit flows to better balance the predominance of large-scale manufacturers and exporters, often the same, with the needs of mid-size high-productivity farming and import substitution industries, especially of intermediate goods. This can be done, among others, through a specialised development finance institution, as he proposes, and/or by reviving credit planning, as suggested earlier.
Naturally, these summary solutions must be supplemented by many details and supportive measures. What this article demonstrates, hopefully, is that there are alternatives to the self-defeating policies that come bundled with IMF money. Policies that we have tried repeatedly, for thirty years, with repeated failures and disastrous results.
“Insanity,” Einstein is reported to have said, “is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.” This article, quite simply, is a plea for sanity.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2022
Arshad Zaman

You might also like

Miradone: Does it Really Work? Should You Give it a Try?

Blooket Play – Join, Play Blooket Games for Classroom

ShowtimeAnytime.com/activate – How to Activate Showtime Anytime?

Excelleren met Excel: Het Belang van een Excel Cursus voor Zakelijk Succes
Trending
Excelleren met Excel: Het Belang van een Excel Cursus voor Zakelijk Succes

The writer has served as Senior Economist with the World Bank in the 1970s and as the Chief Economist of the Government of Pakistan in the 1980s
Comments are closed.

source

Share30Tweet19
Muhammad Mubeen

Muhammad Mubeen

Recommended For You

Miradone: Does it Really Work? Should You Give it a Try?

by Muhammad Mubeen
October 1, 2023
0
miradore

In the world of wellness and alternative medicine, people are constantly seeking natural remedies to improve their health and well-being. One such product that has gained considerable attention...

Read more

Blooket Play – Join, Play Blooket Games for Classroom

by Muhammad Mubeen
October 1, 2023
0
Blooket

Are you searching for an engaging and interactive platform to enhance the learning experience in your classroom? Look no further! We, at Blooket, are here to revolutionize the...

Read more

ShowtimeAnytime.com/activate – How to Activate Showtime Anytime?

by Muhammad Mubeen
October 1, 2023
0
showtimeanytime

Can it be true that you have been hoping to activate Showtime Anytime genuine fast and simple? Assuming this happens, we've your back. Presumably, Showtime is really a...

Read more

7 Ways to Make Home Relocation Less Stressful

by Muhammad Mubeen
July 19, 2023
0
7 Ways to Make Home Relocation Less Stressful

You may have the excitement of moving. You are going to be part of your dream home or job. You can stay nearer to your family and friends....

Read more

Most Experienced Writing Service

by Muhammad Mubeen
July 17, 2023
0
Writing

In today's fast-paced digital world, where content is king, the need for high-quality writing services has skyrocketed. Whether you're a business owner, a student, or an individual looking...

Read more
Next Post
Are there alternatives to a mowed lawn? | News, Sports, Jobs – Evening Observer

Are there alternatives to a mowed lawn? | News, Sports, Jobs - Evening Observer

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News

WVWC student team places second in business competition – My Buckhannon

WVWC student team places second in business competition – My Buckhannon

April 7, 2022
MyMD Pharmaceuticals Announces Live Appearance on Cheddar News Network Today March 24 – Yahoo Finance

MyMD Pharmaceuticals Announces Live Appearance on Cheddar News Network Today March 24 – Yahoo Finance

March 25, 2022
It's terrifyingly easy for reporters to exploit Google's News algorithms – The Next Web

It's terrifyingly easy for reporters to exploit Google's News algorithms – The Next Web

June 10, 2022

Browse by Category

Ads Blog | Blog Roll

Slot Online
News Week
B2B Guru Class
Target Crypto
The Kontent
Hufforbes
Strong Article
ADVERTISEMENT
December 2023
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
« Nov    
ADVERTISEMENT
Strong Article

Strong Article is an ultimate website news portal covering most happening news across the World, business, technology, entertainment, and inventions. This platform is revealing things in an engaging way to improve your knowledge on what is going on across the globe.

Contact us: mubeenh782(@)gmail(dot)com
Telegram:Qualitybacklinks
Whatsapp:+923111339715


CATEGORIES

  • Brand
  • Business
  • Celebrated
  • Crypto
  • Education
  • Electricity
  • Entertainment
  • Features
  • Finance
  • Foods
  • Gambling
  • Health
  • Home
  • Investing
  • Life style
  • Markets
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Pet
  • Politics
  • Real Estate
  • Relationships
  • Small Business
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Travel
  • World

RECENT POSTS

  • Excelleren met Excel: Het Belang van een Excel Cursus voor Zakelijk Succes
  • Miradone: Does it Really Work? Should You Give it a Try?
  • Blooket Play – Join, Play Blooket Games for Classroom
  • History.com/activate – Activate History Channel on Roku, Apple TV & Fire TV
  • ShowtimeAnytime.com/activate – How to Activate Showtime Anytime?

Copyright ©2016. All rights reserved. Strong Article News

No Result
View All Result
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Investing
  • World
  • Technology
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Submit Article

Copyright ©2016. All rights reserved. Strong Article News

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?